From Corporate Prisoner to Thriving Entrepreneur Pam's Blog Moved.

How can you find great mentors?

Get the RSS Feed

When people come to me with questions about how to start or run their business, one of the most frequent pieces of advice I dispense is:  Find yourself a great mentor.

The reason a great mentor is so effective is that you can learn from someone who has already walked down your path and therefore has tested, practical advice.  There are many flavors of mentors, the major categories being:

  • The technical expert:  Mentors in this category are recognized in their particular industry as being the best at what they do.  Sometimes, however, they don’t have a well-rounded skill set.  Larry Ellison of Oracle comes to mind when I think of someone who has great capacity for creating a very successful technology company worth billions of dollars, but is known as being quite Neandrathal in his leadership style. You look to technical mentors to expose you to the smartest, most creative thinking in your field,  not to bare your soul and share your personal fears.
  • The wise elder:  Mentors in this category tend to have both personal and professional insight that they developed over many years.  Yoda comes to mind for a mentor in this category.  These types of mentors are often great for big-picture advice such as “How do I know if I can really trust a new strategic partner?” or “How do I know what will be the key needs in my market 10 years from now?” or “How can I maintain a healthy marriage and still be a successful businessperson?”
  • The few-steps-ahead peer:  Mentors in this category are peers who you respect and admire and have an admirable track record in your field.   I have a number of people in my life who fit this category, and I have chosen them because they set a bar that is challenging but attainable in the short term.  They make me think “If she is doing it, then I can too!”  This kind of mentor is often great for nuts-and-bolts advice such as “What are the top 5 things I should consider when starting a new website?” or “What are the best marketing strategies for reaching parents of Autistic teenagers?” or “How do I register a trade name or set up a patent for a new product?”

Characteristics of a great mentoring relationship:

  • Encouragement. A good mentor will not only provide you with valuable advice, he or she will also help you deal with the fear and stress involved in growing professionally and making a big change.
  • Reciprocity. Enduring mentoring relationships have mutual benefit built into them.  Your mentor may have years of experience in his or her field, but you also must bring something to the table.  Perhaps they are less familiar with technology so you can help them build a website.  Whatever you do, make sure they are not the only ones offering support and advice.
  • Chemistry.  A mentoring relationship is just that, a relationship.  You must truly enjoy each other’s company if it is to last.  If you put each other at ease and make each other laugh, that will make your time together energizing and engaging.
  • Gratitude.  Don’t ever forget to acknowledge and thank your mentor for his guidance and advice.  Lavish gifts or hollow praise are not necessary.  Good, old fashioned heartfelt thanks in the form of a handwritten note or sincere comment work the best.  Let him know what his advice meant to you and how it changed the course of your life.
  • Mutual respect.  Even if people are very well-known in their field, they don’t want to be surrounded by feet-kissing grovelers who deem themselves “not worthy.”  Let me rephrase that.  The mentors you want do not want to be surrounded by arse-kissers.  Be confident and present yourself as a humble, less-experienced equal.

So where do you find mentors?

The paradox of finding a good mentor is that you can’t really look for them, they just show up.  The process reminds me of the children’s book Are You My Mother? A new little bird pokes out of its egg when its mother is off to find a worm, and it falls out of its perch on a tree.  Since it has never seen its mother before, it goes up to every creature it can find and asks “Are you my mother?”  If you look too hard for a mentor, you will force the process and find yourself asking everyone “Are you my mentor?”  That is why I think so many corporate-sponsored mentoring programs struggle, since they try to manufacture what is essentially an organic process.

That said, there are some places you can look for mentors.

  • Work:  Who do you really admire at work?  Do you have former managers who took personal interest in you and offered great advice?
  • School:  Do you have any favorite professors who really influenced your life?  Are there collegues from business school that you always admired?
  • Social or spiritual institutions:  Professional associations, churches or networking groups are great places to look for smart, supportive people.
  • Family.  Your parents or siblings can have natural mentoring qualities that help you grow and develop.  I don’t have any professional success or resounding failure without sharing it with my sister and Dad.  I don’t have any personal challenge or success without sharing it with my Mom.
  • Research.  You may learn about some of your ideal mentors by reading their books or hearing about them in the press.  Don’t be scared off if someone appears too “big” for you. I found one of my dearest mentors Martha Beck by watching her on Oprah, then reading her book.  I knew that she was really busy and well-known, but I just set my sights on getting to know her personally.  It took a couple of years, but now we have a wonderful relationship.  I have had Jim Collins on my list of “ideal mentors” for some time now, and I am sure that sooner or later our paths will cross.

Tips for kicking off a mentoring relationship:

  • Introduce or re-introduce yourself.  If you are approaching someone for the first time or if it has been awhile since you have spoken to them, introduce yourself and get re-acquainted.  “Hi Jim, this is Bob.  I used to work for Suzanne in the Business Development department at Intel.  I was the one with the poor choice in ties – do you remember me?  I was just thinking about you and wondering how you are doing.”
  • Find ways to stay connected.  Find out where they “hang out” professionally and see if you can get to know them better.  Invite them to coffee or lunch and find out what they are working on and what they are interested in.
  • Ask for advice once, then see how it goes.  This is where the organic process comes in.  A natural mentor will be someone who willingly shares advice and information.  Don’t rush into things.  Just ask for advice once and if they seem open, keep the dialogue going .  If they become short or reticent, back off gently and thank them for the advice they gave.
  • Offer support and advice back.  When you find people, information or resources that you feel would benefit your mentor, let them know.  Send articles of interest, make personal introductions or let them know about good products or programs.

Perhaps the best way to create a force field of attraction for a mentor is to be one yourself.  Share what you know with others, and help them to learn and grow.  Your ideal mentor will be watching you too and may just approach you first.

12 Responses to “How can you find great mentors?”

  1. [...] Nice to meet you!  Please, oh please, will you be my mentor? Think about the current mentors in your life.  Did you like and trust them immediately?  Or did your relationship grow with time and work and mutual support?  Sometimes in your desire to learn as much as you can from people you admire, you ask them for specific support and guidance without having any consideration for their time.  A favorite is “you are an expert in my field, would you mind reviewing my 20-page business plan?”Alternative: Respect your own time and that of busy people.  Mentors grow naturally, they are not manufactured.  More tips on finding a mentor here. [...]

  2. If it’s Assigned, it’s Not Mentoring

    This post is for professional service firms who are thinking of starting a mentoring program or who have one and are wondering why it’s not a brilliant success. Assigning mentors doesn’t work. And internal mentoring programs are rife with problems. If …

  3. Great article – thanks very much!

  4. Cindy says:

    Excellent info – Mentors are a very big key to success in business. Once you find a good one, hang on to them!

  5. Marketing Mentor – II

    When mentoring of associates became all the rage, some law firms thought that the solution to keeping new associates happy was to assign them a mentor. They would recruit senior associates or partners willing to participate in the program. But…

  6. Finding (or Becoming) a Great Mentor

    An excellent post at Escape from Cubicle Nation is called How Can You Find a Great Mentor? in which author Pamela Stuart Slim discusses several facts about mentoring and offers must-read advice. She notes there are three types of mentors: The technical…

  7. This is a great post from the perspective of the mentor-seeker. I have mentored a number of young entrepreneurs (crikey, that makes me sound old – I’m only 37!) and several other people have asked me to mentor them. One of the reasons is that I built up and sold a software company before I became a writer. Another is that there is a very popular book in the UK called The Beermat Entrepreneur which encourages every startup to get a mentor.

    Anyhow, the approach usually goes something like this: I get taken to a bar, restaurant or coffee shop and flattered for about half an hour. Then the would-be entrepreneur talks about how exciting their business is. Finally, they ask me to mentor them. Usually, they expect several days a month, indefinitely. Usually, they have no idea of what they can offer in return, either pay, stock or whatever (although I was offered a fat cigar once). It’s not about the money as much as the fact that they have obviously thought I have so much free time that all I want to do is spend it on their business. I’ve learned that the best way to deal with these charming entrepreneur wannabes is to give them my five top tips about starting a business (this list changes depending on my mood) and then ask them to send me a business plan and and say I’ll consider it. So far, of the four or five people who have approached me, none has actually got as far as writing a business plan and, needless to say, none has actually started a business. Looking back on it, I reckon they really wanted me to provide the enterpreneurial juice to get them going and not the occasional bit of advice along the way.

    All this is really to add four points to your post. If you approach a potential mentor:

    1) Be realistic about the commitment you ask for.
    2) Have something to offer in return (doesn’t have to be cash)
    3) Don’t expect them to do your job.
    4) Have a plausible business plan. It’s just like going to a VC except you want time not capital.

  8. What you say here about the mentor who is ‘just one step ahead’ really resonates with me. I’m a novelist and coach and I found my most recent mentor in a coach whose business was just a few steps ahead of my own; I so admired what she was doing and observed her work from afar at first. But it soon dawned on me that all I needed to do was get in touch and I could have that great advice and inspiration directly.

    When I studied creative writing it was with the ‘wise elder’, Sir Malcolm Bradbury. When he told our group ‘this year, you are writers’, it gave the confidence to believe that truth… and hey, I never went back to cubicle nation after that year…

    Thanks for this wonderful post Pamela.

  9. How can you find great mentors?

    Pamela Slim asks how can you find great mentors?
    When people come to me with questions about how to start or run their business, one of the most frequent pieces of advice I dispense is: Find yourself a great mentor.
    The reason a great mentor is so eff…

  10. How do you find a Great Mentor?

    Pamela Slim, author of the blog, ESCAPE FROM CUBICLE NATION: Posted a great piece on How to find a great mentor. When people come to me with questions about how to start or run their business, one of the most

  11. Matt Langdon says:

    I love this post. My favourite part where you echoe Joseph Campbell’s quote (frequently seen in my blog), “We have not even to risk the adventure alone, for the heroes of all time have gone before us” by saying, “The reason a great mentor is so effective is that you can learn from someone who has already walked down your path and therefore has tested, practical advice.”

  12. Jason says:

    Great post! I’m keenly aware now of how much mentors have played a critical role at key stages throughout my life.

    It’s interesting that now I find myself drawn to leaders removed from my immediate world. There are many bloggers I admire, for example, but I have not yet forged personal relationships with any.

    I hope to see this happen for me soon and will definitely take your advice.

Leave a Reply


− 1 = six